How to Make Sure Your Psychological Evaluation is Legally Valid

When you’re getting a psychological evaluation, it’s easy to assume the person you’re meeting with is fully qualified to perform it. After all, they probably have a long list of letters after their name—LCP, LCSW, LMHC, LPC, and more. But what do those letters actually mean, and how do you know if that person is truly allowed to conduct the evaluation you need?

Not every mental health professional is qualified to conduct, supervise, or sign off on an official psychological evaluation. This guide breaks down the different licenses, explains what each one means, and helps you make sure your assessment is valid, ethical, and legally sound.

What Are the Parts of a Psychological Evaluation?

A full psychological evaluation typically includes several important components, each serving a unique purpose in helping your provider understand and assess your mental health needs:

  • The Clinical Interview is the first and most essential step. This one-on-one conversation is between you and a licensed mental health professional. It must be conducted by a mental health professional who is licensed to perform evaluations in the state where the patient lives. During the interview, the clinician gathers detailed information about your background, symptoms, history, and current functioning. This helps set the foundation for any further testing or diagnosis.
  • Psychological Testing comes next. These are structured, standardized tasks like surveys, rating scales, cognitive tasks, or personality assessments. They might be administered by a psychometrician, but they must be interpreted and signed off by a licensed psychologist.
  • The Assessment Process refers to how your clinician reviews all the information collected—your interview responses, test results, behavioral observations, and any external documentation. This step involves compiling all the information into a professional clinical impression or diagnosis. The assessment process must be conducted and interpreted by a mental health professional who is licensed to perform psychological evaluations in the state where the patient lives. Only a licensed professional who meets those criteria may approve the conclusions and recommendations drawn from the assessment.
  • The Final Report is the written summary of the evaluation. It includes your history, test scores, conclusions, and formal recommendations. While the report may be compiled or drafted by a trained assistant or psychometrician, only a licensed mental health professional who was present during your clinical interview and directly involved in your assessment can ethically and legally sign it.

Together, these elements create a full picture of your mental health and ensure the evaluation is accurate, defensible, and useful.

Why This Matters: Legal and Medical Implications

Ensuring your psychological evaluation is performed by an appropriately licensed professional is crucial. An improperly conducted or unauthorized evaluation can have significant legal and medical consequences:

  • Legal Validity: In legal contexts such as court cases, immigration processes, or disability claims, an improperly authorized assessment might be dismissed, negatively impacting your case.
  • Medical Accuracy: Accurate diagnosis and treatment plans rely heavily on qualified assessments. Unqualified or unsupervised evaluations may lead to misdiagnoses or inappropriate treatments.
  • Ethical Standards: Professional accountability and adherence to ethical standards protect your rights and ensure quality care.

Types of Mental Health Professional Licenses Explained

  • Licensed Psychologist (LCP): Holds a doctoral degree in psychology (Ph.D. or Psy.D.) and is licensed to diagnose, treat, and assess psychological conditions independently. They are often involved in complex psychological assessments and therapy.
  • Licensed Clinical Social Worker (LCSW): Holds a master’s degree in social work and is trained to provide therapy and some psychological assessments, often within community and clinical settings.
  • Licensed Marriage and Family Therapist (LMFT): Holds a master’s degree specifically focused on relationships and family systems. Their assessments typically involve relational dynamics rather than individual psychological evaluations.
  • Licensed Mental Health Counselor (LMHC): Holds a master’s degree in counseling and is trained to provide therapy and initial or basic mental health assessments, but typically not comprehensive psychological evaluations.
  • Licensed Professional Counselor (LPC): Similar to LMHCs, LPCs can do counseling and basic assessments, but not full psychological evaluations.
  • PSYPACT Psychologist: A licensed psychologist participating in the Psychology Interjurisdictional Compact, authorized to practice telepsychology and temporary in-person psychology across member states. They must adhere strictly to the licensure requirements of each state involved. It’s important to note that a PSYPACT Psychologist may not sign approval on an evaluation performed by another clinician that is not licensed in the state of practice unless they directly participated in the clinical interview and the assessment process. Doing so would violate PSYPACT rules.
  • Psychometrician: Typically holds a bachelor’s or master’s degree specializing in administering and scoring psychological tests under the supervision of a licensed psychologist. Psychometricians may assist in the assessment process by conducting test batteries and gathering standardized data, but they are not qualified to interpret results or provide diagnoses. They generally do not conduct clinical interviews independently. In most cases, the supervising psychologist must review and co-sign all findings and is typically be required to be present or available during clinical interviews, depending on state regulations and the sensitivity of the case.

Understanding Different Mental Health Professional Licenses

Professional Type Can Independently Perform Clinical Interviews or Assessments? Can Directly Supervise Clinical Interviews and Assessments? Can Sign Assessments When They Didn’t Participate in the Clinical Interview? Can Provide Therapy or Counseling?
Licensed Clinical Psychologist (LCP) Yes Yes Typically, No* Yes
Licensed Clinical Social Worker (LCSW) Limited Scope No No Yes
Licensed Marriage and Family Therapist (LMFT) Relational/Family Only No No Yes
Licensed Mental Health Counselor (LMHC) Initial/Basic Only No No Yes
Licensed Professional Counselor (LPC) Initial/Basic Only No No  Yes
PSYPACT Psychologist Yes Yes, if clinician is licensed in evaluation state only Typically, No* Yes
Psychometrician No, only under supervision No No No

Can Someone Call Themselves a Psychologist Without a License?

Sometimes. If someone has a Ph.D. or Psy.D. in psychology, they may call themselves a “psychologist” in academic or research settings. But that doesn’t mean they are licensed to practice. To provide clinical services, they must be licensed as a Licensed Clinical Psychologist (LCP).

To become an LCP, someone must:

  • Earn a doctoral degree (Ph.D. or Psy.D.)
  • Complete 1,500–2,000 hours of supervised experience
  • Pass a national licensing exam (EPPP)
  • Meet any additional state requirements (like background checks or state-specific exams)

Always check your provider’s license before moving forward with an evaluation.

Checking Your Provider’s License

Before your assessment, always verify the professional license of your provider:

  1. State Licensing Board: Visit your state’s licensing board website and use their verification tool.
  2. Professional Databases: Many states have online databases where you can search by name or license number.
  3. Ask Directly: Don’t hesitate to ask your provider about their credentials and licensing status.

After your assessment, ensure that the person who signed your assessment is someone who was present during your clinical interview.

In nearly all cases where a psychological evaluation is used for legal, medical, or formal documentation purposes, the person who signs the assessment must have been present for the clinical interview. This requirement exists because:

  • The clinical interview is a foundational component of the assessment.
  • The licensed professional is attesting to the validity of the information obtained during that interview.
  • Signing off without being present, especially without direct supervision, could violate licensure laws, ethical codes, and in some cases, state or federal regulations.

There are a few limited exceptions* in research settings or academic contexts, but for clinical purposes (immigration, court evaluations, disability documentation, etc.), the person who signs the assessment must have been present for the clinical interview.

What to Do if Your Assessment May Not Be Properly Authorized

If you suspect your psychological evaluation was performed by someone not properly licensed or authorized:

  • Request Documentation: Ask your provider or the supervising professional for proof of licensure.
  • File a Complaint: If the provider isn’t properly licensed, submit a complaint to your state licensing board or regulatory agency.
  • Seek a Second Opinion: Obtain a reassessment from a properly credentialed mental health professional.

Being informed about your provider’s qualifications ensures your psychological evaluation is credible, valid, and ethically conducted.

About KindestMind

At KindestMind, we believe in transparency, professionalism, and ethical practice. Our evaluations are conducted and reviewed by fully licensed clinicians with deep experience in legal, medical, and psychological documentation. Whether you’re seeking support for immigration, third-party reproduction, autism, or other life needs, we are here to ensure your assessment is thorough, accurate, and fully authorized. If you have questions about our process or the qualifications of our providers, we’re happy to help.

 

Disclaimer: This post is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal or medical advice. For personalized guidance, please consult a qualified legal or mental health professional.

Share this post

Facebook
Pinterest
Twitter
LinkedIn